Design & Manufacturing
When a cheaper part makes the product more expensive
A lower supplier quote can disappear into assembly time, inspection, and rework. Compare the cost of a finished unit before changing the design.
The decision hiding inside the quote
A supplier offers a bracket at a lower price. Purchasing sees a saving; the assembly team sees another adjustment to make on every unit. Both can be right. A component price is only one input to the cost of delivering a working product.
Before approving the substitution, trace what changes downstream. Does the new bracket need a different fixture? Does its finish make inspection harder? Will a tolerance change affect alignment, noise, or service access? A drawing that passes review can still create expensive work on the production floor.
A saving that reverses at the bench
Illustrative example—not a client result: a replacement part costs $4 less but adds six minutes of assembly. At an assumed loaded labor rate of $50 per hour, those minutes cost $5 per unit. The apparent $4 saving becomes a $1 increase before considering scrap, inspection, or tooling.
That calculation is a screening tool, not a final answer. Six minutes saved may release capacity without reducing payroll. Conversely, an extra step at a constrained station may delay more work than its labor cost suggests. State which benefit matters: cash expense, available capacity, delivery time, or product performance.
Run a small comparison before changing the drawing
Build a representative sample of both versions. Record assembly time, adjustments, inspection effort, and rejected units using the same acceptance criteria. Include different operators and realistic variation in incoming parts. A prototype assembled by its designer is not necessarily representative of production.
Compare expected volumes and one-time costs as well. A $3,000 fixture spread across 500 units adds $6 per unit; across 10,000 it adds $0.30. Use a realistic volume range rather than the most optimistic sales forecast. Any change affecting safety or essential performance still needs the appropriate engineering validation.
Bring this to the next design review
Put the current and proposed designs on one page. List purchase price, assembly minutes, inspection steps, expected yield, tooling cost, and the requirement each critical feature serves. Mark estimates separately from measured values.
Assign an owner to the largest unknown and define what evidence would change the decision. The useful outcome is a defensible choice about the complete product—not a cheaper line on a purchase order.